Ali Dover All articles
On Craft

The Girl With the Paperback Was Right: An Apology Owed to My Twenties

Ali Dover
The Girl With the Paperback Was Right: An Apology Owed to My Twenties

Photo: Elias Martin, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons

There is a photograph from the summer I turned twenty-four. It's a backyard cookout in Ohio, string lights, a cornhole board nobody's using, and in the corner of the frame — half out of focus, caught mid-turn toward the door — there I am, a paperback in one hand and a warm beer in the other, clearly on my way somewhere quieter.

For years I used that photo as evidence against myself. Look at her, I'd think. Look at her leaving early again.

The Case Against Twenty-Something Me

The indictment was long. I skipped my college roommate's housewarming because I was three chapters from the end of The Corrections. I let a friendship I loved wither rather than have one uncomfortable phone call. I turned down a road trip to Nashville because I'd just started a novel I couldn't put down, and I remember telling myself, with great seriousness, that the book mattered more.

When people ask what I did in my twenties, the honest answer is: I read. I read on porches and in break rooms and on the L, I read through holidays and breakups and one very bad job interview I'm still not over. I read the way some people run — compulsively, privately, with an air of virtue that covered a great deal of hiding.

I built a whole narrative about it, too. You're avoiding your life, I told myself somewhere around twenty-eight. Books are where you go so you don't have to be a person.

I believed that for a long time. I don't anymore.

What I Actually Learned in There

Here's what I've come to suspect: the girl with the paperback wasn't hiding from life. She was studying it — obliquely, inefficiently, but genuinely — because she didn't yet know how to do it in the room.

I learned how marriages fail from novels before I understood anything about love. I learned what grief does to a household, what resentment sounds like when it's polite, what courage costs when nobody's watching. I watched people make catastrophic choices in safe conditions, over and over, and something in me was taking notes the whole time. When my mother got sick a few years ago, I was terrified — and also, strangely, not surprised by my own terror, because I'd sat with a hundred fictional daughters in that exact hospital chair. I knew the shape of the room.

None of that is a substitute for living. But it isn't nothing, either. Fiction gave me a vocabulary for feelings I couldn't name out loud, and vocabulary turned out to be the thing I needed most when real life finally demanded a sentence from me.

The Conversations I'm Glad I Skipped

I want to be careful here, because this isn't one of those essays where the twist is "actually, avoiding things is great." Some of what I did in my twenties was avoidance, plain and simple, and it cost real people real warmth. The friend I let drift deserved a phone call. The party I skipped out of shyness dressed up as literary seriousness — that was just shyness with better PR.

But here's what I won't apologize for: the hours. The sheer, unproductive, gloriously selfish hours spent with other people's sentences. If I could go back, I wouldn't hand my younger self a pep talk. I'd hand her another book.

Because the conversations I avoided in my twenties? Most of them wouldn't have gone well anyway. I didn't know what I thought yet. I didn't have the words. I got them later, in the dark, one page at a time — and when the hard conversations finally came, in my thirties, I was ready for them in a way twenty-four-year-old me never could have been.

What I'd Tell Her Now

If I could sit down next to that blurred girl in the corner of the photograph, beer going warm in her hand, I wouldn't tell her to stay at the party. I'd tell her this:

The reading isn't the thing you're doing instead of your life. It's how you're building one. Slow down if you want to, say yes sometimes, call the friend — but don't you dare feel guilty about the hours. Some of us learn the world at a desk, through a window made of paper. That's not escape. That's just a different door into the same house.

She'd probably look at me the way she looked at everyone who interrupted her reading — politely, already halfway back to the page.

Good, I'd think. Keep going. It's all going to matter more than you know.

All Articles

Related Articles

Thirty Days of Sounding Like Other People

Thirty Days of Sounding Like Other People

Every Book Deserves a Second Conversation: My Two-Year Rereading Rule

Every Book Deserves a Second Conversation: My Two-Year Rereading Rule

The Book I Read in Secret: A Defense of Unshared Reading

The Book I Read in Secret: A Defense of Unshared Reading